Get in touch

Are You a Good Leader? How Do You Know?

If you asked two of your CRM instructors to assess the same Senior Cabin Crew Member (SCCM), would they reach the same conclusion? And could they explain why?
Human Factors

Ask ten random people what defines a good leader, and you will most likely get ten different answers.

Some will highlight confidence and decisiveness. Others will value empathy, communication, or the ability to stay calm under pressure.

Many of these qualities can be found in good leaders. But there is one substantial problem with unclear definitions.

If we cannot agree on what defines good leadership, how can we standardise the assessment?

If you asked two of your CRM instructors to assess the same Senior Cabin Crew Member (SCCM), would they reach the same conclusion? And could they explain why?

What Are We Really Looking For?

For SCCMs, leadership is not an optional quality. It is part of their operational responsibilities, their ability to work together as a team, make decisions, and promote safety.

Now imagine that you are observing an SCCM during a challenging situation.

They might appear confident, give clear instructions, and make the ‘right’ decision. Does that reflect good leadership?

On the surface, maybe.

But did they also take the time to listen when a colleague raised a concern? Did they consider the workload of the crew before delegating tasks? And did they recognise when the situation required a change of plan?

These observable behaviours tell us a lot more about the SCCM’s leadership competence.

We need to look at behaviour because this is something we can observe, discuss, and assess against defined standards.

From Opinion to Evidence

At EATS 2026, we conducted a workshop, exploring how leadership and non-technical skills can be observed and assessed using relevant behavioural markers.

The principle of assessment may seem straightforward: give people a task, observe how they approach it, assess their performance against clearly defined criteria.

Those criteria could include having clear priorities, inviting input, providing support, adapting plans early, and listening actively.

The challenge is not the observation itself. The challenge is that two instructors may observe the same behaviour but reach wildly different conclusions.

Even with defined behavioural markers, assessment involves human judgement. That is why instructors need the competencies to observe, interpret, and evaluate performance consistently.

Otherwise, we risk measuring the assessor’s personal expectations rather than the crew member’s actual competence.


Assessments with Meaning

A good assessment does not just end with a number on a sheet. The person being assessed needs to understand what they did well, what could be improved, and the reasons why. Giving them the opportunity to assess their own performance is equally important. What they intended to do is not always what others observed.

And when the instructors record their observations consistently, they gain something beyond individual feedback.

They can use this data to identify recurring patterns in communication, teamwork, and decision-making, and use that information to improve CRM training, competency development, and safety management.

So, Are You a Good Leader?

You may very well be. But the question is not whether you believe you are a good leader. Confidence, popularity, or seniority do not determine good leadership.

What matters is how you actually lead when decisions need to be made, concerns are raised, and circumstances change.

In other words, your observable behaviours must support the belief of being a good leader.

And if we want to assess leadership fairly, we need to know what we are looking for.

____________________

This article was inspired by our workshop “Are You a Good Leader? How Would You Know?” at EATS 2026 in Cascais, Portugal.

SMS – The Safety Framework, Not the Fail-Safe

SMS

The Rise and Impact of Competency-Based Training and Assessment

CBTA & EBT

Examining the Scope of Formative and Summative Assessments

Training

5 Ways to Improve Human Factors Training in the Defence Industry

Human Factors
+45 7950 8000
info@aeroteam.dk